Here’s Corey Doctorow’s blurb on the front cover: “A hymn to the ‘deep state,’ which is revealed as nothing more than people who know what they’re talking about.” That pretty much sums things up.
As anti-government sentiment has grown unchecked over the decades, especially among conservative circles, the narrative of government being comprised exclusively of bumbling, inept dolts has become the narrative of choice.
Here’s my take on government: I don’t care if my government is big or if my government is small, I just want it to be smart and effective. My sense is that the current right-wing of America just wants their government to be small and doesn’t care how effective it is in dealing with problems that only governments can deal with. This strikes me as short-sighted and self-defeating.
Case in point: on the morning of November 9, 2016 (the day after Trump’s election), the people in charge of running the U.S. Department of Energy showed up to work fully expecting a team from the Trump transition team to arrive and get briefed on the department’s most pressing issues. By the afternoon, there was still no word. Same with all of Day 2.
Two weeks after the election, DOE staffers read in the newspaper that a small “DOE Landing Team” had been created to handle the transition from the Obama Administration to the Trump Administration.
A month after the election, one guy (Thomas Pyle, lobbyist for Koch Industries) showed up for a briefing. He stayed for an hour. He took no notes. He asked no questions. He never showed up again.
The DOE is a $30 billion a year operation in charge of a whole bunch of stuff. Important stuff like safeguarding our nuclear arsenal. That alone takes up about half the DOE budget. $2 billion goes to tracking down weapons grade plutonium and uranium that is floating around the world. Between 2010 – 2018, the DOE’s National Nuclear Security Administration collected enough material to construct 160 bombs. Given our deep, unrelenting fear of terrorism, this seems like a worthwhile investment…
By Inauguration Day, the Trump Administration’s primary interaction with the DOE was to clear it of all Obama appointees. While that’s not that surprising, there is a long history of appointees from one administration staying on well into the next to provide continuity and training to the incoming team. The Bush Administration’s DOE CFO stayed on for a year and a half into the Obama administration because he had a detailed understanding of the DOE’s finances that was hard to replace on a whim.
Joe Hezir, the DOE’s CFO at the end of Obama’s term, was widely respected across the political spectrum. He assumed he would be getting a call from the incoming Trump team asking him to stay on. By Inauguration Day, no such call had arrived. Not knowing what else to do, the CFO of a $30 billion organization packed up his office and left. With no replacement in sight.
The underlying thread of the anecdotes like the above are a disdain for the work done by government employees.
There’s the guy who spent his career working for the Coast Guard and developed a model to predict how fast and how far kayaks and lifeboats and capsized sailboats and people in water with life vests and people in water without life vests, etc., etc., would float given various wind and water current patterns in the ocean. His work dramatically improved the success rates of search and rescue efforts at sea. This is the work of government, not private enterprise. Trump’s answer: cut research funding.
There’s the guy who spent his career at NOAA fine-tuning tornado predictions, saving untold lives throughout the Midwest. This is the work of government, not private enterprise. Trump’s answer: appoint the CEO of Accuweather to run (and defund) NOAA so that publicly gathered weather data would only be available to Accuweather’s paying clients.
And so on. And so on.
When people in government have a vested interest in tearing down and denigrating government because it fits a narrative, that narrative can become a self-fulling prophecy. Why didn’t the government protect me from a rogue nuclear attack? Or a coronavirus outbreak? Well… it might be because the people responsible for keeping such events from happening are political hacks who show up to their government jobs with an ideological focus on tearing down those very governmental functions rather than a focus of serving the public.
Grr. Tax dollars at work, indeed.
Looking for a copy? Track it down here: http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/1132234996
ReMarkable 